cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
Ben-Dev
Helper II
Helper II

Table.Combine Dies With Stack Overflow

Hello Microsoft Team,

 

I've stumbled across a stack overflow error which rears its ugly head if I try to Table.Combine two tables which are both based on Table.View. 😞

 

Any idea what's going on here, or suggestions on how we can prevent this? Is this a Power Query bug?

 

Cutting it down to the relevant code, here's a repo example which can be demoed in Power BI's Query Editor:

let
    GetView = (state as record) => 
        Table.View(
            null,
            [
                GetType = () => Value.Type(GetRows()),
                GetRows = () => #table({"Col1"}, {{"a"}}),
                OnTake = (count as number) => @GetView(state & [Take = count])
            ]
        )
    ,
    Table = GetView([])
in
    // * The following successfully return a table:
    // Table
    // Table.FirstN(Table, 1000)

    // * All of the following die with: 'Expression.Error: Evaluation resulted in a stack overflow and cannot continue.'
    // Table.FirstN(Table.Combine({Table, Table}), 1000)
    // Table.Combine({Table.FirstN(Table, 1000), Table.FirstN(Table, 1000)})
    Table.Combine({Table, Table})

 

The self-reference (i.e. the above combining Table with itself) doesn't appear to be the issue, as the stack overflow also occurs when two different views are involved:

let
    GetViewA = (state as record) => 
        Table.View(
            null,
            [
                GetType = () => Value.Type(GetRows()),
                GetRows = () => #table({"Col1"}, {{"a"}}),
                OnTake = (count as number) => @GetViewA(state & [Take = count])
            ]
        )
    ,
    GetViewB = (state as record) => 
        Table.View(
            null,
            [
                GetType = () => Value.Type(GetRows()),
                GetRows = () => #table({"Col1"}, {{"a"}}),
                OnTake = (count as number) => @GetViewB(state & [Take = count])
            ]
        )
in
    Table.Combine({GetViewA([]), GetViewB([])})

 

Help here would be much appreciated! Thank you!

4 REPLIES 4
v-jingzhang
Community Support
Community Support

Hi @Ben-Dev 

 

I tested with a simple Table view. It can be combined with itself. 

vjingzhang_0-1653980065243.png

vjingzhang_1-1653980471533.png

Perhaps the issue is due to the code for generating your table view?  

 

Best Regards,
Community Support Team _ Jing

Thanks, @v-jingzhang!

 

I believe the issue here may be related to the combination of Table.Combine and OnTake. From what I'm hearing, sounds like there's an underlying issue which I'll just have to live with.

AlexisOlson
Super User
Super User

I don't know if this helps whatever your ultimate goal is but you can avoid the error by buffering Table to memory.

 

That is, replace 

Table = GetView([])

 with

Table = Table.Buffer(GetView([]))

Hi @AlexisOlson, thanks!

 

Unfortunatley, since buffering blocks subsiquent folding and the real-life Table.View handles more complex folding than is shown in the example, I'm not sure I can realistically use buffering. 

Helpful resources

Announcements
Carousel_PBI_Wave1

2023 Release Wave 1 Plans

Power BI release plans for 2023 release wave 1 describes all new features releasing from April 2023 through September 2023.

Power BI Summit Carousel 2

Global Power BI Training

Make sure you register today for the Power BI Summit 2023. Don't miss all of the great sessions and speakers!

BizApps LATAM 2023

Business Application LATAM Summit 2023

Join the biggest FREE Business Applications Event in LATAM this February.

Power Platform Bootcamp

Global Power Platform Bootcamp

In this bootcamp we will deep-dive into Microsoft’s Power Platform stack with hands-on sessions and labs, delivered to you by experts and community leaders.

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors