Reply
Frequent Visitor
Posts: 9
Registered: ‎11-03-2017
Accepted Solution

calculated column doesn't show blanks

I have a column in the dataset (Query), which has 3 values: 1, 0 and null.

When creating visualizations, I figured I need a different representation of that column. So, I created a Calculated Column:

 

CalcCol = IF(Col1 = 1, "Yes", IF( Col1 = 0, "No", Blank()))

 

But I see only Yes, No values in the new calculated column. I don't see Blanks at all. I think they are combined with No.

 

However, if I crate a Custom column in Edit Queries window to achieve the same, I get all three values.

 

I want to understand why this is the case and would really like to have the calculated column work the desired way, instead of having to create Custom column in edit queries (where it means refreshing the entire dataset and is clumsy given I have lot of huge queries).

 

 


Accepted Solutions
Highlighted
Member
Posts: 76
Registered: ‎05-30-2018

Re: calculated column doesn't show blanks

[ Edited ]

@savvari

This is the intended behaviour. Where boolean logic is involved, blanks are considered as having a numeric value of zero and boolean value of FALSE. What you are essentially saying here is, IF Col 1 = Zero or FALSE, then "No". A boolean comparison of a blank cell to the value of zero ( i.e. IF FALSE = FALSE) equates to TRUE and NOT FALSE, and hence the result. Therefore, one way is to not only compare the values, but also the datatype.

 

 

CalcCol =
IF (
    Table1[Col1] = 1,
    "Yes",
    IF ( ISNUMBER ( Table1[Col1] ) && Table1[Col1] = 0, "No", BLANK () )
)

 

View solution in original post


All Replies
Highlighted
Member
Posts: 76
Registered: ‎05-30-2018

Re: calculated column doesn't show blanks

[ Edited ]

@savvari

This is the intended behaviour. Where boolean logic is involved, blanks are considered as having a numeric value of zero and boolean value of FALSE. What you are essentially saying here is, IF Col 1 = Zero or FALSE, then "No". A boolean comparison of a blank cell to the value of zero ( i.e. IF FALSE = FALSE) equates to TRUE and NOT FALSE, and hence the result. Therefore, one way is to not only compare the values, but also the datatype.

 

 

CalcCol =
IF (
    Table1[Col1] = 1,
    "Yes",
    IF ( ISNUMBER ( Table1[Col1] ) && Table1[Col1] = 0, "No", BLANK () )
)

 

Frequent Visitor
Posts: 9
Registered: ‎11-03-2017

Re: calculated column doesn't show blanks

[ Edited ]

Thanks @nikhilmekala

 

It makes sense. But it's confusing and the expectation is not clear because it behaves differently in Edit Queries window.

 

In the Edit Queries window, I used "Column from Example" option for Adding a column. Had Yes for 1, No for 0 and left nulls as is. That have me three values in the new column. Isn't it the same thing as Boolean logic? I also used Conditional Columns with Rules for 1 and 0. Even in that case, I got Nulls.

 

I'm perplexed as to the difference in behavior between the two cases: Edit Queries window vs Report.