Conditional Formatting stops working when adding a single column

[kritchensBMcD]

I have a very pecular issue.

Right now I have a table with multiple columns and a single column with a conditional formatting.

When I add a column it automatically breaks the conditional formatting but when its taken away the column works as expected. Has anyone ever run into this issue? 

The Column is a Whole Number Type, It is also used for relationships.  If that helps.