A brief comparison of different available Business Intelligence tools

by ask4atish Regular Visitor on ‎05-31-2018 05:32 PM

Robert Mika's wrote an article called Halloween Candies Count - A Tableau/MicroStrategy Dashboard Rebuilt in QlikView.  In this article he replicated A Tableau Dashboard Rebuilt in MicroStrategy over Qlikview to showcase the capability of Qlikview in delivering visualization of the same quality.  After reading this article, and being a Power BI enthusiast,  I decided to do the same thing with Microsoft Power BI.  I used the same data provided by Jeffrey Shaffer, author of the Tableau Version.

 

Comparison

 

Tableau Version of dashboard

Tableau.jpg

 

 

 

MicroStrategy Version of dashboard 

Microstrategy.jpg

 

 

 

Qlikview Version of dashboard

Qlikview.jpg

 

 

Now, I tried to replicate the same version over Power BI. My initial thought while working was to develop exactly the same version of dashboard.

 

Challenges:

 

The grouped line chart is not available in Power BI, but I found a workaround by filtering out different line charts by year...

Markers are not available in Power BI, but not including the marker for the highest number of visitors did not change the overall story on the dashboard.

 

 Here is the Power BI version

PowerBI.jpg

 

Looking at images, someone who doesn't have any experience working on different BI tools would not be able to judge the tool used to visualize the data (all four platforms are showing exactly same view)

 

It was great fun to build this application on Power BI.

 

This activity made me realize that all these tools (Tableau, MicroStrategy, Qlikview and Power BI) are almost same except few things which make them stand unique in the market like Tableau is better in visualization, Qlikview has its associative data model and Power BI has the simplicity which lets a less technical guy to create amazing dashboards . Also, Power BI is really powerful when we talk about its integration with IoT (Internet of Things)-Real time Visual analytics. Right now, Power BI is the only BI tool which is providing real-time visual analytics

 

If you want to explore the Power BI version of the dashboard, please follow this link.

Comments
by yoshihirok Member
on ‎06-02-2018 12:28 AM

Nice, and Power BI Real-Time visual is very nice.

by ben435 New Member
on ‎06-05-2018 03:01 PM
Could you show an example of real-time dashboard on a web page please?
by Julian_camilo Occasional Visitor
on ‎06-19-2018 02:26 AM

Que buena conparacion gracias por el articulo.

by rajendran Senior Member
on ‎07-03-2018 09:40 AM
Excellent, Gives good idea about the available tool abilities.